Advanced Search

Treasury Board and Public Service Alliance of Canada - 1998-05-13

No specific reasons for this suggestion were put forward by Mr. Brisson.   [...]  The only witness who spoke to the reasons for the delay was Angèle Régimbald.   [...]  Reasons for Decision I believe that the extension of time requested by the applicant should be granted.

Imperatore and Treasury Board (Revenue Canada - Customs, Excise and Taxation) - 1998-05-04

The reason for this was Ms. Tilley would have someone else sit at the employee’s desk to do more urgent work, while the employee on overtime would perform work of a less urgent nature at another location.   [...]  However, for whatever reason, he chose not to inform her, if we believe him that he complied with the request.

Wolfe and Treasury Board (National Defence) - 1998-05-04

If the employer has decided to deny me pay-in-lieu, please respond by giving the reasons for such denial.   [...]  He added that I must also determine if the employer exercised its discretion, and if so, if it was exercised in a reasonable way.   [...]  For all these reasons, this grievance is denied. J. Barry Turner, Board Member.

Kilby et al. and Public Service Alliance of Canada and Daryl Bean - 1998-04-27

We do not believe that he can bring about a positive working relationship among and with members of the National Executive for the following reasons . . .   [...]  43. (2) Where the Board, on application to it by the employer or any employee, determines that a bargaining agent would not, if it were an employee organization applying for certification, be certified by the Board by reason of a prohibition contained in section 40, the Board shall revoke the certification of the bargaining  [...]  There can be a myriad of reasons why the Board of Directors voted as they did; there is simply no evidence to suggest that bigotry, racism, sexism or any other improper consideration was behind their decision not to suspend Mr. Pascucci.

Green and Treasury Board (Transport Canada) - 1998-04-06

I agree with the reasoning of the Ontario Court of Appeal, and apply it to the present case.   [...]  Decision Page 11 Reasons for Decision The circumstances of this case pose something of a dilemma for the undersigned.   [...]  Accordingly, for the reasons noted above, the grievance is partially sustained.

Thomson and Treasury Board (Revenue Canada - Customs & Excise) - 1998-04-02

She also added that sometimes the machine would kick in on its own for some strange reason.   [...]  Mr. Snyder argued nine reasons why the grievor’s termination was reasonable. 1.   [...]  For all these reasons, this grievance is denied. J. Barry Turner, Board Member.

Connors and Treasury Board (Revenue Canada - Taxation) - 1998-03-26

Decision Page 7 Accordingly, for all these reasons, the grievances are allowed.

Serniak and Bueckert and Treasury Board (Solicitor General Canada - Correctional Service) - 1998-03-03

Mr. Serniak testified he told Ms. Kubin that the reason for his sick leave was “stress related”.   [...]  These add up to ample reasons for the employer to question their Physician’s Certificates.   [...]  For the above-noted reasons, the grievance of Mr. Serniak is dismissed.

Hanf and Treasury Board (Citizenship and Immigration Canada) - 1998-02-16

But, as Ms. Oberst concluded, the grievor’s poor judgement in this matter required discipline, since the CIC cannot appear to be condoning the falsification of a health certificate, for any reason.   [...]  Argument for the Grievor Mr. Conn argued that the issue before me is one of reasonableness.   [...]  Since the employer has already reduced the original five-day suspension to three days, I see no reason to reduce it further.

Desrochers and Treasury Board (Solicitor General Canada - Correctional Service) - 1998-01-16

Various types of leave were claimed back to back for various reasons.   [...]  (The other reasons for the termination are given at the beginning of this decision.)   [...]  REASONS This grievance is denied for the following reasons. It is my view that the employer discharged the burden of proof and that it established on the weight of the evidence the facts alleged against Louis Desrochers.

Hutchinson and Treasury Board (Environment Canada) - 1998-01-14

(1) Subject to this section, where an employee while at work has reasonable cause to believe that   [...]  It is my opinion that for medical reasons, Ms. Hutchinson is not able to work efficiently and effectively in the Queen’s Square workplace, and I believe that it is reasonable for her to refuse to work there unless and until her medical condition improves.   [...]  Mr. Bangay did not find her reasons for declining work in Exhibit E-24 very compelling.

Tucci and Hindle - 1997-12-29

The reasons for concern were that some Stewards were not keeping PIPSC staff and the regional officers informed as to what was going on.   [...]  In this instance, it has been demonstrated that there was no legitimate reason in denying Luigi Tucci representation.   [...]  Decision Page 15 Reasons for Decision The Board’s authority to address complaints with respect to the representation of bargaining agents is found in subsection 10(2) of the Act, which states as follows: Fair representation 10.

Edwards and Treasury Board (Agriculture & Agri-Food Canada) - 1997-12-22

Even if work is discontinued, management can still reasonably refuse payment.   [...]  Under all the circumstances, I do not consider it to have been a "reasonable" job offer.   [...]  For all these reasons, this grievance is allowed. J. Barry Turner, Board Member.